Direct-to-garment (DTG) printing and screen printing are the two most widely used techniques in custom apparel printing. Each has advantages of its own, and the secret to successful custom apparel printing is selecting the right technique for your needs.
This comprehensive guide analyzes the two techniques in-depth, covering their benefits and drawbacks as well as ideal uses, to help you make an informed choice. This article will give you useful reference information whether you’re new to printing or want to improve the efficiency and quality of your current printing.
In the field of modern textile printing, DTG printing and screen printing are the two main technologies. Understanding these two printing methods helps you choose a printing solution that suits your needs.
Direct-to-garment (DTG) printing is a modern printing technique that uses inkjet technology to print patterns directly onto textiles. Full-color, detailed, high-resolution printing can be achieved using this technique.
The results produced by DTG printers are vivid and long-lasting because they use unique water-based inks that are absorbed by fabric fibers. This technology is ideal for small batch, diversified, and personalized printing needs, because there is no need to make templates, short setup time, and can quickly meet market needs.
Screen printing, also known as silkscreen printing, is a traditional method. It needs to make a template (or screen), and then use it to put multiple layers of ink on the printed surface. This technology can print bright colors and durable effects, especially suitable for large-volume orders. The multi-color design process will involve more steps because each color needs its own screen.
However, screen printing has a very high efficiency once the template is ready, making it appropriate for mass manufacturing. Because of its durability and cost-effectiveness, screen printing is still widely used in custom apparel.
DTG printing provides excellent print quality, so how does it work? Below we will explore how DTG printing works so that you can better utilize this technology to achieve high-quality printing results.
The garments must be pre-treated with a unique solution before printing. This stage is crucial to ensuring that the ink adheres firmly to the fibers so that the print results are clear and lasting.
The pre-treatment solution can be applied evenly to the surface of the fabric using a spray gun or an automatic machine. Because the application and drying duration of the pre-treated solution will impact the quality of the final print, this step needs to be strictly controlled and monitored.
After the pre-treatment, the garments are loaded into the DTG printer. The design file is made in the graphics software and sent to the printer. DTG printers use inkjet technology to spray water-based ink directly onto the fabric. The print head moves back and forth across the garment to precisely apply the ink.
Unlike traditional printing methods, DTG printers can complete multi-color printing on the same surface in one go, without the need for layering or color separation. Because of this, DTG printing is perfect for intricate multicolored designs that require high-resolution gradients and details.
After printing, the garments are cured to hold the ink in place. Curing is usually done by heating with a hot press or conveyor dryer. The heat allows the ink to stick better to the fabric fibers, improving the durability and washability of the printed pattern.
The curing time and temperature should be adjusted according to the type of ink and fabric used to achieve the best results. Correct curing can not only enhance the color saturation and durability of the pattern, but also prevent the pattern from falling off during washing.
Now that you know how DTG printing works, let’s take a look at how screen printing works. It is mainly divided into the following three processes:
Creating a template or screen is the first stage in the screen printing process. First, choose the proper fine mesh material, which is typically stainless steel or polyester. Pull the fine mesh onto the frame and apply the emulsion. Next, the pattern’s negative is applied to the screen, and the exposure procedure is used to transfer the pattern to the screen.
The emulsion will solidify when the screen is exposed to intense light, but the area that the pattern blocks will remain soft. After exposure, the screen is rinsed with water to wash away the emulsion that has not hardened, and the pattern template is formed on the screen. This step requires precise control to ensure clear pattern details and edges.
When the screen is ready, it is installed on the press. Before you start printing, place the fabric or material to be printed under the screen. Then pour the ink onto the top of the mesh and push it evenly across the mesh template with a squeegee, and the ink will pass through the mesh and onto the fabric underneath. This requires even pressure and angles, ensuring that the ink is evenly distributed and the pattern is clear.
In order to prevent color mixing in multi-color designs, each color must be applied separately using a screen and ink, and it is best to let the ink dry slightly after each application. Because of this, multi-color silk screen printing requires additional steps and is more sophisticated than monochrome design.
After the pattern is printed, the garments are cured to hold the ink in place. A conveyor belt dryer is typically used for curing, and it moves slowly to let the print pass through the heated area. The printed pattern is guaranteed to be washable and long-lasting since the heat solidifies the ink’s bond with the fabric fibers.
To get the finest results, the curing temperature and time should also be adjusted based on the kind of ink and fabric. To make sure that every product is up to the standard, final inspection and finishing are typically required after curing.
The main reason for the popularity of DTG printing technology in the custom apparel industry is that it offers many advantages. The following are some of the main advantages of DTG printing:
DTG printing is well known for its capacity to generate detailed, full-color, high-resolution prints. DTG printers use advanced inkjet technology, which gives exact control over the application of ink, producing graphics that are detailed and vibrant.
DTG printing produces very similar printing results to the original design document because it can generate fine color gradients and fine pattern edges by spraying ink directly into the fabric fibers. Especially for products that need to display intricate patterns, minute details, or lifelike photos, this premium printing is perfect.
Because of its extreme versatility, DTG printing can be used in a wide range of materials, including cotton, blends of polyester, and some synthetic materials. This versatility allows DTG printing to meet the needs of different customers.
Furthermore, DTG printing does not require the laborious process of traditional screen printing, where each color requires its own template, and can effortlessly handle intricate, multi-colored designs and photographic pictures. DTG printing is perfect for small batch production and tailored custom products because of its tremendous flexibility.
DTG printing is suitable for both novices and small businesses, as it is comparatively simple to set up and operate. DTG printing is far simpler than screen printing, which calls for the creation of numerous templates and intricate setups. All that’s needed is to submit the design file to the printer, which prints it straight onto garments. This cuts down on preparation time significantly and streamlines the setup procedure.
In addition, modern DTG printers, such as the Incolorprint DTG printer, are often equipped with user-friendly software interfaces and automation features that make operation easier and more efficient, even for inexperienced operators.
One of the significant advantages of DTG printing is that it is cost-effective for small orders and one-time designs. DTG printing enables on-demand production without requiring a minimum number of orders, in contrast to screen printing, which requires a lot of setup for every design.
This means that DTG printing can offer a cost-effective solution for any kind of custom apparel need, whether it’s a small business or an individual customer requiring a personalized T-shirt in small quantities. Because of its flexibility, DTG printing has an obvious advantage when it comes to handling customer customization requests and reacting quickly to market demands.
For many mass production and special effects applications, screen printing is the preferred printing method. Here are some of its main advantages:
When processing big orders, screen printing is incredibly economical. After the template is made, printing will become quick and simple, making it ideal for large-scale production. Additionally, the cost per piece decreases as you print more.
Therefore, screen printing is much more appealing for bulk orders, particularly for customers who require hundreds or even thousands of the same design. In addition, you can save money by using the mesh template again and again.
Screen printing is known for its durability. The design is resistant to repeated washing and wear since the ink is thicker and more deeply absorbed into the fabric fibers. The print does not fade or flake easily, even after extended use. It still stays bright.
Because of its durability, screen printing is particularly well-suited for items like work garments, sportswear, and often washed clothing that needs to retain their attractive look for a long time.
Screen printing can print highly vivid and opaque colors, especially on dark fabrics. The pattern appears bright and clear on a variety of materials because the thick ink ensures color saturation and coverage.
Screen printing allows the use of a variety of special inks, such as metallic, luminous, and fluffy inks, which can add unique effects and textures to the print, making the product more eye-catching and unique.
The ability to produce a variety of special effects and inks is a big advantage of screen printing. These include metallic inks, glitter inks, and textured inks that can add unique visual and tactile elements to print designs.
Screen printing is more advantageous when it comes to designs that involve innovation and personalization because of these exceptional effects, which also satisfy customers’ demands for distinctive printing effects.
Although DTG printing technology has many advantages, there are also some disadvantages that need to be considered.
DTG printing is typically more expensive per print than screen printing, particularly for larger quantities. DTG requires special water-based inks and pre-treatment solutions, in addition to machine maintenance and operation costs, so the cost of single piece printing is high.
Therefore, DTG’s cost performance is not too high for orders needing mass manufacturing. On the contrary, when screen printing handles a large number of orders, the cost of each piece of print will decrease significantly as the number increases.
In general, DTG printing takes longer than screen printing, particularly for larger orders. Layer-by-layer inkjet is needed for DTG, which takes longer than a screen to apply ink. Additionally, handling each garment separately adds time to the overall production process.
Even with the speed improvements in recent years, executing large orders at a screen printing speed is still challenging for DTG printers. This slower printing speed may limit the application of DTG in high-demand, high-speed production environments.
Although DTG printing has a wide range of applications, it is not suitable for all types of fabric. Cotton and cotton blends work best because these fabrics absorb water-based inks well and print bright, durable colors.
However, for synthetic fabrics such as polyester and nylon, the printing effect may not be ideal due to poor ink absorption. Ink tends to fade or fall off on these fabrics, affecting print quality and durability.
Like DTG printing, screen printing also has many advantages, but it also has some obvious disadvantages.
Screen printing needs a more involved setup procedure than DTG printing. Each color requires a separate screen template, which means that several templates need to be made for each new design.
This preparation process is not only time-consuming and labor-intensive, but also requires highly specialized skills and equipment. Therefore, the preliminary preparation work of screen printing is usually more cumbersome and laborious than DTG printing.
Screen printing is great for creating prints with vivid colors and durability, but it is not as good at reproducing fine details and photographic images, especially when working with delicate lines or complex patterns. This means that in screen printing, a very detailed design might not produce the intended fine effect.
In contrast, DTG printing can produce intricate, high-resolution pattern printing. Therefore, it can be a preferable option when it comes to high precision and complexity.
Screen printing is less economical for smaller orders because of setup time and cost reasons. Each design requires a separate screen, which increases the upfront cost and time investment. Therefore, screen printing is not very cost-effective for one-time designs or small-batch production.
In contrast, DTG printing offers more benefits when dealing with small orders because it can print directly and doesn’t require complicated preparatory preparation.
Both DTG printing and screen printing have their own unique advantages and disadvantages, and understanding the differences between the two methods can help you choose the most suitable printing solution. Below we provide a detailed comparative analysis of the two printing technologies.
DTG Printing: Known for high resolution, full color printing and complex details. DTG printers can accurately inkjet on fabric to print vivid and detailed designs, especially for gradients, photos, and small text designs. As a result, DTG printing works particularly well where detail and precision are needed.
Screen Printing: Known for producing bright, opaque colors and excellent durability. Screen printing uses thick ink, which can print very bright colors on dark fabrics. It is suitable for bold designs with solid colors, but not very suitable for very detailed or multi-colored designs. Because each color uses a separate screen, it can be troublesome to achieve complex multi-color designs.
DTG Printing: When dealing with large orders, DTG printing speed is relatively slow. Because inkjet technology needs to apply ink layer by layer, the processing time for each piece of garment will be longer. Therefore, DTG printing is more suitable for small batch and on-demand production, because speed is not a key factor.
Screen Printing: Once the screen is set up, screen printing is very fast when handling large orders. Rapid printing of ink through screens makes mass production more efficient. Therefore, for the need to quickly process a large number of orders, screen printing is more suitable.
DTG Printing: The cost of each print is relatively high, especially when dealing with large orders. Because of the increased cost of the special water-based inks and pretreatment solutions used, it is not cost-effective in mass production. However, for small batch and one-time designs, DTG printing saves money because it does not require complex upfront setups.
Screen Printing: When processing large orders, the cost per print is significantly reduced. Although the initial setup cost is high, the cost per product will be greatly reduced after the order volume increases. Therefore, screen printing is more cost effective for large orders, but small batch production is less economical.
DTG Printing: Suitable for small and medium-sized businesses with order volumes in the low to medium range. DTG printing is ideal for personalization and on-demand printing because there is no need for complex up-front setup and flexibility to handle different designs and small orders.
Screen Printing: With strong scalability, suitable for mass production and large order volume enterprises. Screen printing has obvious efficiency and cost advantages when dealing with large-scale operations, and is very suitable for large volume orders.
DTG Printing: Due to the use of water-based inks, the DTG printing process produces less waste and is generally considered more environmentally friendly. Water-based inks have less impact on the environment during use and handling, making DTG printing a more sustainable option.
Screen Printing: During screen preparation and cleaning, screen printing may produce more waste, including too much ink and chemicals. However, by using environmentally friendly inks and adopting more environmentally friendly practices, the environmental impact of screen printing can be reduced.
The right printing method has a great impact on print quality and cost-effectiveness. Both DTG printing and screen printing have benefits and drawbacks, and they are suitable for different needs. There are some key factors to consider when choosing which printing method to use.
First, assess your specific needs. Order volume, design complexity, fabric type, production speed, and other factors will affect whether you choose DTG printing or screen printing.
For example, if the order volume is small and fast delivery is required, DTG printing may be more suitable. But if mass production is required, screen printing is more advantageous. Therefore, according to your actual situation, evaluate which printing method is more suitable.
Also, consider the budget for initial setup and ongoing production costs. DTG printing may have a higher upfront cost per print, but is more economical for small batches.
Screen printing requires a large initial investment in the screen and setup, but for large orders, the cost per piece is low. So when choosing a printing method, you need to consider your budget and expected order volume.
Another important factor is the volume and frequency of orders. If the order volume is large and often mass produced, then screen printing may be more cost advantageous. Because screen printing can handle a large number of products at once, it is very suitable for large-scale production.
However, if the order is smaller and requires personalized design and on-demand production, then DTG printing will be more suitable. Because it can respond quickly to small batch and single piece orders.
Design complexity is also an important factor. For highly detailed designs, photo images, and multi-color printing, DTG printing provides superior quality and precision. DTG specializes in complex patterns and color gradients, making it ideal for high-quality custom printing.
Screen printing is best suited for bold solid color designs, as well as the use of special inks, such as metallic ink or fluorescent ink. Screen printing works well when dealing with simple, sharp patterns, and color saturation is high.
With the development of technology and changes in the market, apparel printing is also constantly changing. Below are some key future trends that will have an important impact on the apparel printing industry.
Both DTG printing and screen printing technology continue to advance, and innovations such as improved ink formulations, faster printing speeds, and automated processes are improving print quality and efficiency.
For example, DTG printing is moving toward greater color accuracy and durability, and new inkjet technology makes printed images more realistic and durable. In terms of screen printing, the introduction of automation equipment has greatly improved production efficiency and reduced errors caused by manual operation.
Consumers increasingly like personalized products, which makes printing companies continue to improve their ability to customize services. DTG printing and screen printing are constantly innovating to meet the changing needs of a diverse and dynamic market.
DTG printing is the first choice for online retailers and small businesses due to its fast response and small batch customization. Screen printing is still important in the field of mass production.
The apparel printing industry will become more and more sustainable. For example, water-based inks used in DTG printing are favored by more and more enterprises because of their low toxicity and environmental protection.
At the same time, printing companies are also working to reduce waste in their production processes and achieve sustainable development goals through recycling and optimizing processes. The use of sustainable materials and energy-efficient equipment is also becoming more widespread, reducing the burden on the environment.
Numerous considerations, including printing quality, speed, cost, scalability, and environmental impact, need to be taken into account when choosing between DTG printing and screen printing. You also need to consider your needs, budget, order volume, and design complexity to select the best printing method.
DTG printing specializes in creating fine, high-quality prints that are perfect for on-demand and small-batch production. In addition to offering vivid, long-lasting prints with a range of special inks and effects, screen printing is more cost-effective for larger orders.
As the custom apparel printing industry changes, staying up to date with the latest technology, market trends, and sustainability initiatives will help you maintain your competitive edge and success in this quickly expanding field.
QUICK LINKS
CONTACT US
Guangzhou Yincai Intelligent Technology Co., Ltd.
We are always providing our customers with reliable products and considerate services.
If you would like to keep touch with us directly, please go to contact us